I'm partial to DO/AWS because I see both Heroku and Modulus as Golden handcuffs [0]. If you like Heroku/Modulus then I would look into things like Dokku/Dokku-alt, Deis, Flynn, etc. All of them support buildpacks so you can probably get your application running and once you have it running on any of those platforms you can run it on any cloud infrastructure that you want and you can even switch clouds fairly easily (spin up new nodes in new cloud, move old nodes out of load balancer).
All of that said I get the appeal of Heroku/Modulus and you might be just fine staying with them until traffic/users require more dynos/servos then looking for alternatives. I can't really suggest moving off H/M without knowing more about your product and how you will need to scale it.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_handcuffs