I can't reply to Porker! But.. in reply, yes, I agree, critical analysis is horribly lacking in science atm.
Maybe this is something a plenary could do well - what are the assumptions that underpin some of the things that we are doing? Can we challenge those? Can we pick out the complaints/problems that people outside have about what we are doing?
That's hard for any community to do...
BTW. for the record, I learned years ago that objects did not for a good modularity make...