I read that here, my memory was a little off -
https://web.archive.org/web/20170302073322/http://www.ign.co...>"In doing our testing without the touch features we noticed looking back and forth between the Gamepad and the screen actually took a little something away from this type of Zelda game," he said.
>"There was no hesitation or reluctance in removing those features because we felt the way it is now is the best way to play the game," he added.
I can understand the cynicism, but, to me anyway, I agree that it's not ideal gameplay. The game pad was a big miss for me for anything other than being able to play a game when my husband was using the TV. I ended up kinda hating the gamepad.
So I believe both can be true.